APA, MLA and Chicago
Annotated bibliography
- An annotated bibliography is a list of sources in which each entry is followed by a short paragraph about it: what the source says, how far it can be trusted, and what you will use it for.
- Each entry is formatted exactly as in that style's reference list, hanging indent included. What differs is the annotation beneath it.
- APA indents the whole annotation half an inch, as a block. MLA allows short phrases after the entry, or full sentences after a line space. Chicago lets it follow the entry or start a new line.
- MLA titles the list Annotated Bibliography or Annotated List of Works Cited, and its guidance adds that writing an effective annotation requires reading the work.
Below: the three things an annotation does, three examples and where each stops, and each style's rules from its own text.
What an annotation holds
Three things. An assignment may ask for one, two or all three, so read the brief before you write twenty of them.
Summary
What the source claims, and on what basis. Not what it is about: a summary that could be written from the title is not a summary.
Assessment
How good it is and how far it reaches: what kind of source it is, who collected the data, how large the study was. A review and an experiment support different kinds of claim, and saying which is which is most of the assessment.
Reflection
What it does for your project: which chapter it belongs in, which argument it supports, what it cannot be used for. It is the one part nobody can write without your project.
MLA adds a rule in the negative: an annotation should not rehash minor details, cite evidence, quote the author, or recount the steps in an argument. If yours quotes the source, it has turned into notes.
Length follows the assignment. APA leaves the number of sources and the length and focus of each annotation to the instructor; where nothing is set, one tight paragraph per source is usual.
Three annotations, and where each stops
The same four sources as the citation generator pages, in APA 7. Each annotation was written from its source's own abstract or release text, so it goes no further than that text.
Journal article
LeCun, Y., Bengio, Y., & Hinton, G. (2015). Deep learning. Nature, 521(7553), 436–444. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature14539
A review article on deep learning. It explains how models built from many processing layers learn representations of data at multiple levels of abstraction, with backpropagation as the means by which each layer's internal parameters are adjusted. It describes how far these methods have moved the state of the art in speech recognition, visual object recognition and object detection, and in fields such as drug discovery and genomics, and it separates convolutional nets, suited to images, video, speech and audio, from recurrent nets, suited to sequential data such as text and speech. As a review it reports no experiment of its own: it maps the field and grounds the convolutional–recurrent distinction, but it is not evidence for any single empirical claim.
Conference paper
Zoph, B., Yuret, D., May, J., & Knight, K. (2016). Transfer learning for low-resource neural machine translation. Proceedings of the 2016 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing, 1568–1575. https://doi.org/10.18653/v1/D16-1163
Proposes a transfer learning method for neural machine translation in low-resource languages. A model is first trained on a high-resource language pair, the parent, and some of its learned parameters are then transferred to the low-resource pair, the child, to initialize and constrain its training. The authors report BLEU gains over baseline systems on four low-resource language pairs and, with ensembling and unknown-word replacement, results close to a strong syntax-based system, ahead of it on one pair. The evaluation covers four language pairs, so the paper supports the method on those rather than for low-resource translation in general.
Book
Bandura, A. (1997). Self-efficacy: The exercise of control. W. H. Freeman.
No annotation, on purpose. A book has no abstract, and the three above were written from their sources' own summaries; one for this book written from less than the book would be invented. MLA's guidance puts it plainly: writing an effective annotation requires reading the work.
Web page
U.S. Census Bureau. (2022, February 24). Census Bureau releases new educational attainment data. United States Census Bureau. https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2022/educational-attainment.html
A Census Bureau release of findings from the Educational Attainment in the United States: 2021 table package, which uses the Current Population Survey's Annual Social and Economic Supplement to describe the highest level of education reached by adults age 25 and older, by demographic and social characteristics. It is the agency's own release of its own survey, so it is the source to cite the figures from, and its levels of attainment are the agency's definitions, which need naming wherever a figure is used.
None of the three says what its source does for a project, because none has a project behind it. That sentence is yours to write, and it is the one an abstract cannot give you.
How APA, MLA and Chicago set out the annotation
Each style formats the entry as it would in its reference list, with the hanging indent. The rules below are for the paragraph under it, from each style's own text.
APA 7
Publication Manual, 7th edition, section 9.51
- Entries in alphabetical order, formatted as in a reference list.
- Each annotation is a new paragraph below its entry.
- The whole annotation is indented 0.5 in. from the left margin, like a block quotation, and its first line gets no extra indent.
- A second paragraph in the same annotation indents its first line a further 0.5 in.
- The number of sources and the length and focus of each annotation are set by the instructor.
MLA
MLA Style Center, “Annotated Bibliographies” (written for the eighth edition)
- Each source styled as in a list of works cited, with the annotation added at the end.
- Short phrases can run on after the entry. Complete sentences start after a line space, with a paragraph indent.
- The list is titled Annotated Bibliography or Annotated List of Works Cited.
- Order by author or title, by date of publication, or by subject.
- No rehashing minor details, citing evidence, quoting the author, or recounting the steps of an argument.
Chicago
The Chicago Manual of Style, 17th edition, 14.64
- Entries formatted as in the bibliography.
- An annotation may simply follow the publication details, in brackets if only a few entries are annotated.
- Or it may start a new line, often indented from the left margin.
MLA's post was written for the eighth edition; the entries on this site follow the ninth, and the two agree on styling the entry as in a works-cited list. Where your assignment brief or department guide sets a form, it overrides all three.
Building one in Grongy
Start for freeThere is an outline for it. Choose Annotated bibliography as the document's structure and it opens with two headings, Introduction and Annotated Entries, ready to write into.
Each source you cite comes from a record, a paper in your library or a result from the scholarly indexes, so a citation resolves to something you can open. On Plus and Pro the reference list builds itself in the style you choose, from 9 built-in styles and more than 10,000 CSL styles, and switching style rebuilds it from the stored records.
It does not write the annotations. There is no annotation generator and no per-style template, because an annotation is a judgment about a source you have read, which is the part MLA says cannot be skipped.
Annotated bibliography questions
How long should each annotation be?
As long as your brief says; APA leaves it to the instructor too. Where nothing is set, one paragraph per source is usual. The useful limit is the three jobs an annotation does: say what the source claims, judge what it is worth, and state what you will use it for.
Is an annotated bibliography the same as a literature review?
No, and the difference is structure, not length. An annotated bibliography is organized by source, one entry at a time. A literature review is organized by argument, and one of its paragraphs may draw on six sources at once. The annotated bibliography is often the step before the review.
Can I write annotations from the abstracts?
Only the summary, and only as far as the abstract goes. MLA's guidance says writing an effective annotation requires reading the work; an abstract tells you little about how far a source reaches or what it is good for in your project, which is most of what an annotation is for.
Does the hanging indent apply?
To the entry, yes, as in any reference list. The annotation is set differently: APA indents the whole paragraph 0.5 in. with no extra first-line indent, MLA starts full-sentence annotations after a line space with a paragraph indent, and Chicago lets the annotation follow the entry or start a new line.
Do I cite the source inside its own annotation?
In APA, no: the entry above it already identifies the source. If the annotation mentions other works, cite those in the text as usual.
What do I call the list?
In MLA, Annotated Bibliography or Annotated List of Works Cited, not Works Cited. For APA and Chicago, use the heading your brief gives.
Related guides
- How Many Sources for a Literature Review: Why No One Can Tell You
No one can give you a defensible number. We measured reference counts in 11.3 million dissertations in OpenAlex, and the measurement itself shows why.
Start your work
Join 1,000+ researchers and students and start with a free account.