Compared on the record · checked October 2026

Elicit alternative — the chapter is what you are marked on

You are not marked on the table. You are marked on the chapter. In Grongy the papers you kept become the draft written from them, every citation resolves to a record, nine checks read the result before your supervisor does, and the record of how it was written stays with the document. Screening thousands of candidates is a different job with a different output, and this page says where the line falls.

Five differences between an evidence table and a chapter

01

What you are marked on

An extraction run ends in a table: a row per paper, columns you defined. A thesis chapter ends in prose with citations in context, a reference list, and an argument that holds together. Asking which is better is like asking whether a spreadsheet beats a chapter. The honest question is which one has your name on it at the end of the term.

02

Nine checks read the chapter

An independent examiner model reads the draft you have, including the parts AI wrote, and the panel runs nine checks: academic review, language and clarity, sources and citations, source integrity, journal readiness, document health, format against your university’s guideline, submission readiness, and the questions a viva panel is likely to ask. Scope is yours — a selection, a section, or the whole thesis.

03

Every citation in the draft resolves to a record

Drafting reads the papers in your project and cites those. A page locator has to name a page we actually indexed or it is removed; a quotation of six words or more has to be in the source’s own text or the quotation marks come off; a sentence sharing ten consecutive words with the passage the model was given is thrown away. Then the audit reads claim and source together, up to 120 pairs in a run, returning one of five verdicts with a confidence score. On our own benchmark of 110 claims across 26 papers it produced no false positives and was exactly right on 89.1% of them (run of September 15, 2026).

04

The twenty to two hundred papers that end up in a bibliography

That is the set a thesis actually cites, and it is the set this is built around. A synthesis matrix fills a fixed set of columns — focus, population, sample, method, finding, limitation — for up to 60 sources in the project. Source screening flags a retracted paper, a DOI the registry does not know, a duplicate record and a preprint, and it spends no credits. Elicit’s paid workflows screen at a scale no writing tool attempts: their own pages describe screening 5,000 papers, and 40,000 at the enterprise tier.

05

Your data, your interviews, and the prose itself

A spreadsheet that opens and saves .xlsx files sits in the project, with formulas and statistical tests reported in APA style, Cronbach’s alpha, and PROCESS mediation and moderation. Interviews are coded in a qualitative tab that reports Cohen’s kappa between two coders. And when the prose needs a plainer register, the rewrite cuts AI-like filler and stiff phrasing while the meaning, the technical detail and every citation stay in place — with no manufactured typos, no forced slang and no staged asides, because faking a careless human is not the same as writing clearly.

Grongy vs Elicit, side by side

Elicit's side is taken from elicit.com and its pricing page, read on 22 October 2026, in their own terms. Their tiers and caps are described there and are not reproduced here, because a page that pins itself to another product's plan table is wrong by next quarter.

GrongyElicit
The outputA document with headings, footnotes and a reference list, exported to Word, PDF, LaTeX or Markdown.Structured tables, reports and screening decisions across a set of papers.
DraftingDrafting whose every citation resolves to a record, with no setting that lets a citation come from the model’s memory.Not a chapter-writing tool, and does not present itself as one.
Reviewing the chapterNine review checks — academic review, language, sources, source integrity, journal readiness, document health, format against your university’s guideline, submission readiness and defense preparation.Screening decisions and extraction quality, by their own description.
Checking the citationsAn audit that reads claim and source together and returns one of five verdicts with a confidence score, up to 120 pairs in a run; on our own benchmark of 110 claims across 26 papers (September 15, 2026) it produced no false positives and was exactly right on 89.1%.Supporting quotes beside each extracted value, by their own description.
ExtractionA synthesis matrix that fills a fixed set of columns (focus, population, sample, method, finding, limitation) for up to 60 sources in the project.Columns you define, extracted across a set of papers.
Source integrityRetractions, unregistered DOIs, mismatched records, duplicates and preprints, flagged on the sources in the project without spending credits.Screening against criteria you define, by their own description.
Your own dataA spreadsheet with formulas that opens and saves .xlsx files, statistical tests reported in APA style, Cronbach’s alpha, PROCESS mediation and moderation, and interview coding with Cohen’s kappa.Not part of what their pages describe.
SearchOpenAlex, Crossref and DOAJ on every search, plus PubMed and arXiv when the topic fits; OpenAlex alone held more than 320 million records when we measured it in October 2026.Unlimited search across more than 138 million papers on their free tier, by their own description.
Scale of the setThe papers that end up cited, with the citation audit reading up to 120 claim-source pairs in a run.Workflows described as screening 5,000 papers, and 40,000 at the enterprise tier.
Reference exportsThe reference list, BibTeX and RIS export and a live BibTeX link for your library on Plus and Pro, and the document to Word, PDF, LaTeX or Markdown.RIS, CSV, BIB, PDF and DOCX from their paid tiers, by their own list.
The record of AI useA paragraph-by-paragraph record of where AI was used in the document, with the word count and no control to delete or hide it.Explanations for AI-generated answers at the higher tiers, by their own description.
What the tool is forA workspace for academic research, where the document, its sources and its data live together.AI for scientific research, in their words — search, summarize, screen and extract.

What this does not do

The scope is narrow on purpose, and the narrow part is written down.

  • It does not screen thousands of candidates, and it draws no PRISMA flow diagram. A PRISMA 2020 chapter structure is a different thing, and that is what exists here.
  • It does not invent data, participants, measurements or results.
  • A claim your sources do not support stays uncited rather than receiving a reference.
  • You read the papers, write the argument and remain the author of what you submit.

If you want to move over

Screening ends where the writing starts, and the papers that survived move as a file.

  1. 1

    Screen wide, where screening is the job

    Get from thousands of candidates down to the set that actually matters, with your inclusion criteria written down.

  2. 2

    Bring the survivors in as records

    Their paid tiers export RIS and BIB, by their own list, and both import here directly along with .enw. The metadata comes with them, which is what a reference list is rebuilt from.

  3. 3

    Write the chapter from the records

    Draft each section against the papers you kept. A sentence the sources do not support stays uncited, and a citation that resolves to nothing is dropped from the paragraph.

  4. 4

    Audit, review, disclose

    Check the claim-source pairs in the finished text, run the nine review checks and the pre-submission list, then write your AI-use statement from the record kept while you worked.

Questions

Can Elicit write my literature review?

It can give you the evidence base and a table that organizes it, which is a large part of the hard thinking. The review you submit is prose: an argument, citations in context, and a reference list that holds. That is what this is built for — the papers you kept, the draft written from them, the audit that reads each claim against its source, and nine checks over the result.

Do I need both tools?

For a thesis chapter, usually not. For a systematic review, screen first and write second, because the two halves have different outputs. The papers that survive screening export as RIS or BIB and import here directly.

Is Grongy’s search as big as Elicit’s?

Elicit describes more than 138 million papers on its free tier. Grongy searches OpenAlex, Crossref and DOAJ on every query, with PubMed and arXiv when the topic fits; OpenAlex alone held more than 320 million records when we measured it in October 2026, and the legal open-access PDF arrives through Unpaywall where one exists. Size is the easy part, though. What happens after a paper is saved is the harder one: the citation that resolves to it, the claim checked against it, and the record of how the text was written.

Which one do supervisors prefer?

They have no view on tools. They have a view on whether your claims are supported, your method is stated and your limitations are honest. The review panel reads all three, and the citation audit answers the first source by source.

Start your work

Join 1,000+ researchers and students and start with a free account.